NAACP and LULAC Release Central Health 'Red Flag' Report

March 24, 2022

NAACP and LULAC Release Central Health

'Red Flag' Report, Call on Commissioners to

Order an Independent Performance Audit 


AUSTIN, Texas ------ Today, March 23, 2022, at 1:30 p.m., at 700 Lavaca (Eastside Plaza) in Austin, Texas, Health Equity First, a new joint project of NAACP-Austin and Texas LULAC District VII, released a detailed report showing that Central Health has eight serious financial, operational, and equity red flags. These red flags serve as a warning to the Travis County Commissioners Court (TCCC) and community that Central Health must be held accountable for providing healthcare effectively to the poor and for spending taxpayers funds efficiently. Health Equity First called on the Commissioners to immediately order a comprehensive, independent, third-party performance audit of Central Health. 


Frank Ortega, Director of Texas LULAC District VII, stated that “Travis County’s 185,000 uninsured are predominately people of color. They depend on Central Health for their health care. Health Equity requires that Central Health serve the poor’s health care needs effectively.”


Nelson Linder, President of the local NAACP chapter, said, “TCCC have financial supervisory authority by law over Central Health. Our “Eight Red Flags Report” shows the TCCC should order immediately an independent, performance audit to ensure Central Health accountability and transparency. Without accountability, there is no equity.”


Susan Spataro, former Travis County Auditor, discussed Central Health’s red flags and why an independent, third party audit of Central Health was essential. She pointed out, for example, that “the community deserves answers to why, during a pandemic, Central Health has raised this fiscal year its tax rate by 6%, but it has decreased health care services to the poor by 34% from $155.1 million to $101.8 million.” She also noted, “The Commissioners and public need to know exactly how much health care, if any, the poor have received from Dell Medical School for $280 million in Central Health property taxpayers funds. We also need to know if the care has been accessible and high quality.”


Nelson Linder concluded, “people of color deserve health equity in Travis County. An audit is essential to knowing whether Central Health is fairly and effectively serving the poor.”


The “Red Flags” report will be distributed at the press conference. A brief list of the red flags is on page 2 of this release. You can learn more about Health Equity First and view the full Red Flag Report and sources at HealthEquityFirst.com 

 

Additional quotes and interviews are available upon request, please contact info@healthequityfirst.com or visit HealthEquityFirst.com for more details.


###



 Central Health’s 8 Red Flags in Brief

Each red flag alone should call for an independent, third-party performance audit. Together, the eight flags direct that the Travis County Commissioners Court exercise immediately supervisory authority over Central Health (CH) to protect the county’s poor and its property taxpayers. The eight red flags are:


  1. The Federal HHS Inspector General found $83 million in impermissible provider-related payments involving the Community Care Collaborative (CCC), Seton and CH’s nonprofit partnership.
  2. Ascension Seton (CH’s hospital care provider) paid a $20 million fine for alleged provider kickbacks.
  3. Partners Ascension Seton and CH are in a protracted contractual and funding dispute over Seton’s provision of hospital care for the poor. 
  4. The CCC has no approved budget, and CH and Seton have discontinued their CCC annual payments.
  5. CH’s contingency reserves have multiplied eight-fold from $36.6 million to $298 million in the last five years for unclear reasons. CH’s contingency reserves this year are three times larger than the amount it spend on direct health care for the poor.
  6. The Dell Medical School has received $280 million from CH but has never produced any documentation of the amount of direct health care it has delivered for these property tax funds. CH promised voters in 2012 “… a specific amount of the estimated $54 million a year in new tax revenue - $35 million - would be permanently earmarked for services provided to needy patients by the medical school's faculty and residents…” Austin American-Statesman (October 14, 2012). There is no evidence that happened.
  7. CH purports to have low administrative costs (3%), but actually its non-health care costs appear to be at least 35%-- almost 12 times greater than CH presented to the TCCC.
  8. Despite repeated costly failures to establish an integrated delivery system, CH is planning major expenditures to develop a new “Equity-focused Service Delivery System.”

 

Please see the full Red Flag Report here for details and sources.

 

###

There Can Be No Equity Without Austin Healthcare Accountability
April 21, 2022
Austin Chronicle Opinion By Nelson Linder and Frank Ortega: When It Comes to Health Care in Austin, There Can Be No Equity Without Accountability. It’s time for the Travis County Commissioners Court to order an independent performance audit of Central Health
March 7, 2022
NAACP AUSTIN ANNOUNCES SXSW LAUNCH OF ‘HEALTH EQUITY FIRST’ CAMPAIGN
February 27, 2022
Why is Central Health financing the Dell Medical School? A new short documentary by Austin filmmaker Steve Mims questions why a big portion of taxpayer funds collected for the care of the poor in Travis County are instead being used to fund the operations of Dell Medical School. Through Central Health, the county hospital district, Travis County taxpayers fork over $35 million per year to Dell Medical School in perpetuity. This arrangement dates to 2012, when voters approved an increased Central Health property tax, “including support for a new medical school.”
February 27, 2022
In November 2012, Austin voters were asked to approve a proposition that promised to expand health care for the poor. They approved a ballot measure creating a pool of $35 million in tax money each year for the nonprofit Central Health, an agency charged by the state with funding indigent health care and hospitalization in Travis County. Voters were told that the money would go to a new medical school at the University of Texas, where the poor would be treated. But in 2017, Travis County taxpayers filed a lawsuit claiming that voters had been duped and that little or none of that money had been spent for clinical care; instead it was funding UT administration, research and support salaries. That lawsuit is ongoing. A short documentary, called “Inquest: An Examination of Central Health,” has now been released on YouTube. The Observer spoke with attorney and activist Fred Lewis, who with Austin filmmaker Steve Mims and Brian Rodgers, co-produced the 30-minute film that raises tough questions...
February 27, 2022
NAACP Austin President Linder is quoted in the recent Austin-American Statesman article saying, "Addressing people who are most affected by this pandemic requires community involvement and communication from government officials and all of our community organizations. But I don't see that happening."